v1: Two years after the earlier word, see 1.1,7; the temple is not yet complete, Ezra 6.15.
v2-3: The question to the Lord God relates to their fasting, which is evidently a regular practice, and has been for many years. They are apparently looking for His approval of their lives.
v4-7: The response from the Lord; He does not challenge their claims; but He does challenge their devotion, "was it really for me?" He asks. Their feasting and drinking is similarly "just for yourselves." Here is a challenge to motives and priorities. It is commendable that they have continued their rituals for 70 years or more, but their ritual clearly lacked and lacks real meaning.
The Lord calls for devotion and obedience, as the earlier prophets have declared. Since their ritual is empty, there is a call to repentance. Their exile in Babylon was due to persistent disobedience, not the failure to fast or to practice other rituals.
v8-10: Specific areas to be addressed; true justice and mercy and compassion;
- consider the widow the orphan, the foreigner, the poor;
- do not think evil of each other.
Their actions and thoughts must match, and be pleasing to God, see 8.16-17.
v11-14: The reminder of what happened years before, and an implied warning for today;
- they refused to pay attention;
- stubbornly they turned their backs; and
- stopped up their ears;
- they made their hearts as hard as flint;
- would not listen to the law of to the words the Lord Almighty had sent.
In these descriptive phrases, the prophet describes the people's disobedience. As a consequence of this, the Lord was "very angry."
As a result, the people were scattered, and the land left desolate. It is clear that persistent disobedience brings consequences. For many Jews, their persist in empty ritual.